CONTACT: MARY GERAGHTY
100 Old Public Library
Iowa City IA 52242
(319) 384-0011; fax (319) 384-0024
Journal ranks UI political science department fourth in nation
IOWA CITY, Iowa -- A new list in a leading political science journal
ranks the University of Iowa department of political science fourth in
the nation based on the number of publications by its faculty in the top
journals in the discipline. The list, published in the journal PS: Political
Science and Politics, ranks departments by quality of publications per
"This study factors out the halo effects of faculty size and university
reputations. The result is the disciplinary standing of the departments
by the quality of their journal publications," said John Nelson, chairman
of the UI political science department.
In an article that analyzes the rankings, the authors note that the
overall size of faculties and the general reputations of universities distort
earlier studies of department quality, including the ones compiled by the
National Research Council.
Failing to adjust for size, the authors explain, can punish a small
department. Iowa has only 23 faculty members in political science. By
contrast, the University of Michigan has 52 faculty members in the same
"If rankings are unavoidable, then let them reflect actual rather
than perceived research, departmental achievements as distinct from university
prestige, and faculty productivity rather than departmental size,"
the PS authors write. Setting aside the advantages of large size and university
reputation, Michigan falls from 3rd in the NRC ranking to 33rd in the PS
study. Iowa climbs from 25th to 4th.
According to PS, the top 10 political science departments are: California
Institute of Technology; State University of New York - Stony Brook; University
of Rochester; University of Iowa; University of Houston; Carnegie Mellon
University; Michigan State University; Texas A&M University; Stanford
University; and University of Georgia.
Big Ten political science departments among the top 50 are: University
of Iowa (4); Michigan State University (7); Ohio State University (11);
University of Minnesota (18); Indiana University (19); University of Michigan
(33); and University of Wisconsin-Madison (44).